Some seafood spots try hard to look fancy.
New York Seafood Restaurant in St. Petersburg, NY doesn’t bother with that — and honestly, that’s part of its charm. Locals don’t come here for trends or décor; they come because the seafood is fresh, portions are generous, and prices feel fair for New York standards.
This is the kind of place where regulars already know what they’re ordering before they sit down — which usually tells you everything you need to know.
🍽️ What Kind of Restaurant Is New York Seafood Restaurant?
New York Seafood Restaurant is a casual, local-style seafood spot focused on classic American seafood favorites.
You won’t find experimental plating here — instead, expect straightforward seafood done right, from fried baskets to grilled plates.
Best for:
- Local families
- Seafood lovers
- Casual lunches & relaxed dinners
- Takeout orders
Seafood Restaurant St. Petersburg Menu with Price
Deep Fried Menu
| Salmon | $14.95 |
| Grouper | $14.95 |
| Basa | $13.95 |
| Tilapia | $11.95 |
| Catfish Nugget | $11.95 |
| Fried Shrimp | $10 |
Salad Menu
| Shrimp Salad | $6.50 |
| Chicken Salad | $5.95 |
| Conch Salad | $8.95 |
Side And Seafood Specials Menu
| Special A | $20 |
| Special B | $28 |
| Special C | $18 |
| Andy Special | $15 |
| Andy Special | $18 |
| Neckbone Tray | $18 |
Special Dishes Menu
| Spaghetti | $11.95 |
| Ramen #1 | $5 |
| Ramen #2 | $10 |
| Conch Pasta | $10 |
| Conch + Shrimp Pasta | $15 |
Sides Menu
| Corn | $2 |
| Potato | $2 |
| Sausage | $3 |
| Eggs | $3 |
| Broccoli | $3 |
| Mushroom | $2 |
| Peanut | $4 |
| Neckbone | $4 |
| Steamed Rice | $2 |
| French Fries | $3 |
Drinks Menu
| Canned Soda | $2 |
| Bottled Water | $1 |
| Bottled Juice | $3 |
Chicken & Curry Menu
| Chicken Bites | $5.99 |
| Wings | $7.95 |
| Chicken Tenders | $7.99 |
| Shrimp Curry | $14.99 |
| Beef Curry | $13.99 |
| Chicken Curry | $14.99 |
Noodles Menu
| Spaghetti | $6 |
| Cajun Shrimp Pasta | $6 |
| Garlic Conch Pasta | $10 |
Chinese Food Menu
| Green Pepper Steak | $6 |
| Shrimp Fried Rice | $8 |
| Beef Fried Rice | $8 |
| Stir-Fry Beef | $6 |
| Sweet & Sour Chicken | $6.95 |
Stirred – Fry Menu
| Chicken Broccoli | $12 |
| Shrimp Broccoli | $12 |
| Teriyaki Chicken | $12 |
| Pepper Streak | $15 |
Appetizers Menu
| Wings | $6 |
| Chicken Tender | $5.95 |
| Crab Rangoon | $4.95 |
Sauces Menu
| Garlic Butter | Lemon Pepper Garlic Butter |
| Cajun Butter | Onions & Garlic Sauce |
| House Sauce |
Fried Rice Or Lomien Noodle Menu
| Shrimp | $15 |
| Chicken | $12 |
| Vegetable | $10 |
| New York Special 1/2 Lb Snowcrab | $12 |
Others Menu
| Canned Soda | $2 |
| Lemonade | $3 |
| Oyster | $22 |
| Shrimp Broccoli | |
| Chicken Broccoli | |
| Pepper Steak | |
| Black Mussel | $10 |
| Pina Colada | |
| Mango Sunset | |
| Peach Paradise | |
| Vegetable | $9.95 |
| House | $10 |
| Sc #1 | $25 |
| 1/2 Lb Shrimp | $9 |
| 1/2 Lb Green Mussel | $10 |
| 1/2 Lb Black Mussel | $9 |
| 1/2 Lb Crawfish | $9 |
Seafood Trays Menu
| Green Mussel | $12 |
| Shrimp + Green Mussel | $12 |
Seafood Addon
| 1/2 Lb Baby Clams | $6 |
| Scallop | $6 |
| 1/2 Lb Conch Meat | $15 |
| 1/2 Lb Dungeness | $15 |
| Lobstertail | $18 |
Neckbone Combos Menu
| Lynn Special | $8 |
| Large Neckbone Tray | $15.95 |
| Happy Tray #1 | $12 |
Sandwiches Menu
| Tilapia | $4.95 |
| Catfish | $4.95 |
| Basa | $4.95 |
| Snapper | $5.95 |
| Grouper | $7.95 |
| Salmon | $5.95 |
| Grilled Chicken | $4.95 |
| Roasted Pork | $4.95 |
| Roasted Beef | $5.95 |
Fish Or Shrimp Menu
| Salmon | $14.95 |
| Snapper | |
| Grouper | |
| Basa | $13.95 |
| Tilapia | $11.95 |
| Catfish Nugget | $11.95 |
| Fish+ Shrimp Basket | $13.95 |
| Fried Shrimp | $14.95 |
📖 New York Seafood Restaurant Menu (Popular Picks)
ℹ️ Menu items and prices may change. Always confirm at the restaurant.
🦀 Seafood Favorites
- Fried Shrimp Basket
- Fish & Chips
- Fried Clams
- Crab Cakes
- Steamed Shrimp
🐟 Grilled & Baked Options
- Grilled Salmon Plate
- Baked Fish with Sides
- Seafood Combo Platters
🍟 Sides & Add-Ons
- French Fries
- Coleslaw
- Hush Puppies
- Corn on the Cob
🥤 Drinks
- Soft Drinks
- Iced Tea
- Lemonade
💡 Local Tip: Most regulars recommend combo platters if you want variety without ordering multiple dishes.
⭐ Google Reviews & Customer Ratings
Based on public feedback, New York Seafood Restaurant St. Petersburg NY maintains a strong local reputation.
What customers often praise:
- Fresh-tasting seafood 🐟
- Big portion sizes 🍽️
- Quick service for takeout
- Affordable pricing compared to chain seafood restaurants
Common feedback notes:
- Simple interior
- Peak hours can get busy
- Limited seating at times
⭐ Average Local Rating: 4.0 – 4.3 out of 5
🪑 Atmosphere & Dining Experience
The atmosphere is relaxed and no-pressure.
You’ll see families, working professionals grabbing dinner, and longtime customers chatting casually.
Don’t expect:
- Fancy lighting
- Instagram décor
Do expect:
- Friendly service
- Fast food turnaround
- Comfortable local vibe
🤔 Is New York Seafood Restaurant Worth Visiting?
If you’re looking for:
✔️ Honest seafood
✔️ Good portions
✔️ No unnecessary pricing drama
Then yes — this place is absolutely worth a visit.
If you want upscale dining or fine-dining seafood, this may not be your spot.
But for real, everyday seafood that locals rely on, it delivers.
🏁 Final Local Verdict
New York Seafood Restaurant in St. Petersburg, NY feels like a place built for the neighborhood — not tourists. It’s dependable, familiar, and focused on what matters most: good seafood at reasonable prices.
Sometimes, that’s better than any trendy restaurant.
📍 Location, Contact & Online Presence (Short)
- 📍 Location: St. Petersburg, New York, USA – Click Here
- 📞 Phone: (Check Google Maps for latest number) – Click Here
- 🌐 Google Maps Listing: Available – Click Here
- 📱 Social Media: Limited / Local listing presence – Facebook
- Website – Click Here
Conclusion
The New York Seafood Restaurant in St. Petersburg is a top choice for seafood lovers looking for fresh, flavorful, and affordable options. With a diverse menu featuring fried shrimp, crab legs, lobster tails, and other fresh seafood selections, this family-owned and operated market and takeout restaurant delivers both quality and value. Whether you’re craving a quick takeout meal or searching for the freshest catch to cook at home, New York Seafood has you covered.
If you’ve enjoyed dining at a seafood restaurant in Manhattan or trying an authentic New York seafood boil, you’ll love the flavors and quality here. This spot rivals some of the top 10 seafood restaurants in New York City, offering a taste of New York-style seafood right in St. Petersburg. If you’re searching for seafood near me, this hidden gem is a must-visit!
❓ Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1. What is New York Seafood Restaurant known for?
It’s best known for fried seafood baskets, combo platters, and generous portions at fair prices.
Q2. Is New York Seafood Restaurant family-friendly?
Yes, it’s a casual spot suitable for families and groups.
Q3. Does the restaurant offer takeout?
Yes, takeout is popular and often recommended during busy hours.
Q4. Are prices affordable?
Compared to many New York seafood spots, prices are considered reasonable.
Q5. Is this a fancy seafood restaurant?
No. It’s more of a local, casual seafood restaurant focused on food quality.
You must read
- Taco Bell Dollar Menu Guide (2026): Luxe Value Items Changes, Breakfast Prices, Desserts, Calories, Best Items & Box Deals
- Best Cape Cod Restaurants for 2026: Seafood Favorites, Hidden Gems, and Waterfront Dining
- Burger King Menu Breakfast Guide: Prices, Hours, Nutrition, Lunch Deals & New Menu Changes (2026)
- Keens Steakhouse Menu: Prices, History, Reservations, and What to Expect 2026
- 🍳 Jack’s Wife Freda Menu Prices in New York, USA 2026