If you’re walking around Staten Island craving a classic New York–style pizza with Italian comfort food vibes, My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY is one of those local spots people quietly trust. It’s not flashy — it’s familiar, affordable, and built for everyday dining.
This place is popular with local families, office workers, and late-night pizza lovers who want good food without overthinking it.
🍽️ What Kind of Restaurant Is My Pizza?
My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY is a casual Italian-American pizza restaurant serving:
- New York–style pizza
- Pasta & baked Italian dishes
- Comfort food classics
- Takeout & delivery-friendly meals
It’s more of a neighborhood pizza joint than a tourist restaurant — which is exactly why locals keep coming back.
My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island New York Menu with Price
Slices
| Regular Cheese Slice | $ 2.52 |
| Pepperoni Slice | $ 3.25 |
| Sicilian Slice | $ 3.00 |
| Veggie Slice | $ 3.50 |
| Grandma Slice | $ 2.75 |
| White Slice | $ 3.25 |
| Margarita Slice | $ 3.50 |
| Vodka Slice | $ 3.50 |
| Buffalo Slice | $ 4.25 |
| Alfredo Slice | $ 4.25 |
| BBQ Slice | $ 4.25 |
| Philly Cheese Steak Slice | $ 4.25 |
| Chicken Tomato Onion Slice | $ 4.25 |
| Chicken Marsala Slice | $ 4.25 |
| Chicken Francaise Slice | $ 4.25 |
| Chicken Tomato Broccoli Slice | $ 4.25 |
Cheese Pie
| Large Pie 16“ | $ 12.99 |
| Half & Half Large Pie 16″ | $ 12.99 |
| Med Pie 14″ | $ 11.99 |
| Half & Half Med Pie 16″ | $ 11.99 |
| X Large Pie 18″ | $ 17.99 |
| Half & Half X Large Pie 18“ | $ 17.99 |
| Sicilian Pie Deep Dish Square Pie | $ 17.99 |
| Half & Half Sicilian Pie | $ 17.99 |
| Personal Pie 10″ | $ 7.99 |
| Grandma Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Garlic, Marinara Sauce, Basil & Grated Parmigiana | $ 19.99 |
| Full Pan Pie Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Garlic, Marinara Sauce, Basil & Grated Parmigiana | $ 24.99 |
| Half & Half Pan Pie | $ 12.99 |
Calzones & Rolls
| Cheese Calzone | $ 5.95 |
| Calzone w.Meat | $ 6.95 |
| Calzone Veggie | $ 6.95 |
| Chicken Roll | $ 6.00 |
| Buffalo Chicken Roll | $ 8.00 |
| Beef Peperoni Roll | $ 6.00 |
| Beef Sausage Roll | $ 6.00 |
| Eggplant Roll | $ 6.00 |
| Spinach Roll | $ 6.00 |
| Broccoli Roll | $ 6.00 |
| Philly Steak Roll | $ 8.00 |
| Stromboli Roll | $ 8.00 |
Appetizers & Side
| Garlic Knots Oven baked knots drizzled with butter topped with cheese & spices | $ 2.00 |
| Zeppole’s Deep fried dough covered in powdered sugar | $ 3.00 |
| French Fries Crunchy deep fried potato fries | $ 4.00 |
| Mozz Sticks (6) Deep fried breaded sticks of melted mozzarella served with marinara sauce | $ 6.50 |
| Beef Patties Jamaican style ground beef patty mixed with spices & wrapped in a flaky shell | $ 3.00 |
| Chicken Tenders (4 Pcs) Crunchy breaded chicken tenders | $ 6.50 |
| Chicken Fingers (4 pcs) | $ 6.50 |
| Potato Croquettes (2) Home made deep fried crispy potato croquettes served with marinara sauce | $ 5.00 |
| Rice Ball Deep fried balls of rice and mozzarella cheese | $ 4.50 |
| Onion Rings Batter fried crispy onion rings | $ 6.00 |
| Garlic Bread Oven baked bread with garlic, butter & spices served with marinara sauce | $ 3.50 |
| Fish N Chips Breaded crispy fish with fries on the side served & tartar sauce | $ 7.50 |
| Fried Calamari Deep fried extra crispy calamari served with marinara sauce | $ 10.95 |
| Fried Jumbo Shrimps (6) Shrimp grilled until golden and crunchy | $ 10.95 |
| Grilled Jumbo Shrimps (6) Shrimp grilled until golden and crunchy | $ 10.95 |
| Fried Chicken Garlic Knot Bun Bread roll with fried chicken, marinara sauce, garlic, cheese & red peppers | $ 6.00 |
| Grilled Chicken Garlic Knot Bun Bread roll with grilled chicken, marinara sauce, garlic, cheese & red peppers | $ 6.00 |
| Grilled Chicken (2) Chicken seasoned and grilled until golden and crunchy | $ 5.95 |
| Fried Chicken (2) Chicken seasoned and fried until golden and crunchy | $ 5.95 |
| Meat Balls (2) Home made ground beef meatball with seasoning | $ 5.95 |
| Beef Sausage (2) Beef sausages as a side | $ 5.95 |
| Saute Broccoli Broccoli seasoned and sauteed | $ 5.95 |
| Saute Spinach Spinach seasoned and sauteed | $ 5.95 |
Wings Planet
| Wings 5 pcs | $ 7.99 |
| Winds 8 pcs | $ 9.99 |
| Wings 10 pcs | $ 11.99 |
| Wings 15 pcs | $ 15.99 |
| Wings 20 pcs | $ 19.99 |
| Wings 20 pcs | $ 19.99 |
| Wings 50 pcs | $ 48.99 |
Burger, Gyro & Wraps
| Burger Bun with ground grass fed angus beef | $ 5.50 |
| Cheese Burger Bun with ground grass fed angus beef & American cheese | $ 5.95 |
| Cheese Burger Deluxe Cheese burger with fries on the side | $ 7.95 |
| Half Pounder Burger Deluxe Half Pound of ground grass fed Angus Beef on a bun | $ 10.95 |
| Veggi Burger Deluxe Veggi burger with lettuce, tomato, onion on a bun with fries & tahini sauce on the side | $ 7.95 |
| Chicken Gyro Gyro chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion on a pita bread & tzatziki sauce | $ 5.95 |
| Chicken Gyro Deluxe Gyro chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion on a pita bread with fries & tzatziki sauce | $ 7.95 |
| Lamb Gyro Gyro lamb with lettuce, tomato, onion on a pita bread & tzatziki sauce | $ 6.95 |
| Lamb Gyro Deluxe Gyro lamb with lettuce, tomato, onion on a pita bread with fries & tzatziki sauce | $ 8.95 |
| Double Cheese Burger Bun with ground grass fed angus beef & American cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Fried Chicken Caesar Fried chicken with romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing & melted parmigiano cheese | $ 7.95 |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Grilled chicken with romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing & melted parmigiano cheese | $ 7.95 |
| Grilled Chicken Delight Wraps Grilled chicken with iceberg lettuce, tomato with mayonnaise | $ 8.95 |
| Buffalo Chicken Wraps Sauté chicken cubes in homemade buffalo sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Chicken Française Wraps Egg battered chicken cubes in a lemon sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Chicken Marsala Wraps Sauté chicken & mushroom in marsala sauce topped with mozzarella cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Philly Cheese Steak Wraps Thinly sliced beef with onions, peppers topped with melted American cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Shrimp Parm Wraps Breaded jumbo fried shrimp in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese | $ 11.95 |
| Tuna Wrap | $ 8.95 |
Foot Long Heros
| Chicken Cutlet Hero Breaded & seasoned chicken cutlet with marinara sauce | $ 8.95 |
| Chicken Parmigiana Hero Breaded & seasoned chicken with marinara sauce topped with parmigiana | $ 9.95 |
| Grilled Chicken Hero LTM Seasoned chicken with lettuce, tomato & mayo | $ 8.95 |
| Fried Chicken Hero LTM Seasoned chicken with lettuce, tomato & mayo | $ 8.95 |
| Buffalo Chicken Hero Sauté chicken in homemade buffalo sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Chicken Française Hero Egg battered chicken in a lemon sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Meatball (Beef) Hero Meatballs with marinara sauce | $ 8.95 |
| Meatball (Beef) Parmigiana Meatballs with marinara sauce | $ 10.45 |
| Veal Parmigiana Hero Veal cutlet with marinara sauce & cheese | $ 11.95 |
| Sausage (Beef) Hero Sausages served with marinara sauce | $ 8.95 |
| Sausage & Peppers Hero Sausages with green bell peppers in marinara sauce | $ 8.95 |
| Eggplant Hero Golden fried eggplant with marinara sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 7.95 |
| Eggplant Parm Hero Golden fried eggplant with marinara sauc topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Potato & Egg Hero Freshly cooked Idaho potato and eggs | $ 7.95 |
| Pepper & Egg Hero Freshly cooked peppers and eggs | $ 7.95 |
| Philly Cheese Steak Hero Thinly sliced beef strips grilled with onions topped with American cheese | $ 8.95 |
| Philly Chz Stk Mush Hero Thinly sliced beef strips grilled with onions and mushrooms | $ 8.95 |
| Special Philly Cheese Steak OMP Thinly sliced beef strips grilled with onions, mushrooms & peppers topped with American cheese | $ 9.95 |
| Shrimp LTM Fried jumbo shrimps (4) with lettuce, tomato & mayo | $ 10.95 |
| Shrimp Parm Hero Fried jumbo shrimps (4) with marinara sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese | $ 10.95 |
Salads & Soups
| Tossed Salad Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions | $ 5.95 |
| Tossed w.Grilled Chicken Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces | $ 8.75 |
| Tossed w.Fried Chicken Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces | $ 8.75 |
| Mixed Green Salad Locally harvested baby lettuces, arugula, frisee and spinach | $ 5.95 |
| Buff Chicken Salad Buffalo style chicken cubes with lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions | $ 6.95 |
| Ceasar Salad Romaine lettuce, croutons topped with freshly graded parmigiana cheese | $ 5.95 |
| Ceasar w.Grilled Chicken Romaine lettuce, croutons topped with freshly graded parmigiana cheese w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces | $ 8.75 |
| Ceasar w.Fried Chicken Romaine lettuce, croutons topped with freshly graded parmigiana cheese w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces | $ 6.95 |
| Grilled Shrimp Salad Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives, onions topped with jumbo shrimps (6) | $ 13.95 |
| Fried Shrimp Salad Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives, onions topped with jumbo shrimps (6) | $ 13.95 |
| Lentil Soup Lentils with carrots, onions & garlic | $ 5.95 |
| Pasta Fagioli Soup White bean & pasta cooked with garlic & spices | $ 5.95 |
| Chicken Noodle Soup Shredded chicken cooked in onion, celery, carrots with seasoning & noodles | $ 5.95 |
| Minestrone Soup Tomato broth cooked with vegetables, beans & pasta | $ 5.95 |
| Tortellini & Spinach Soup Chicken broth with tomatoes, spinach & tortellini | $ 5.95 |
Entrees
| Chicken Parmigiano | $ 13.95 |
| Chicken Française | $ 13.95 |
| Chicken Marsala | $ 13.95 |
| Chicken Sorrentino | $ 15.95 |
| Meatball Parm dn | $ 13.95 |
| Eggplant Parmigiana | $ 13.95 |
| Eggplant Rollatini | $ 13.95 |
| Calamari in Marinara Sauce | $ 14.95 |
| Shrimp Parmigiana | $ 16.95 |
| Shrimp Scampi | $ 16.95 |
| Veal Cutlet Parm | $ 15.95 |
Pasta & Baked Pasta
| Pasta w.Marinara Sauce Choice of pasta with marinara sauce | $ 8.95 |
| Pasta w.Meat Sauce Choice of pasta with meat sauce | $ 9.95 |
| Pasta w.Garlic & Oil Choice of pasta tossed in garlic & olive oil | $ 8.95 |
| Pasta w.Broccoli, Garlic & Oil Choice of pasta with broccoli tossed in garlic & olive oil | $ 8.95 |
| Pasta w.Meatball (Beef) Pasta with Meatball (Beef) | $ 10.95 |
| Pasta w.Sausage (Beef) Pasta with Sausage (Beef) | $ 10.95 |
| Pasta w.Vodka Sauce Choice of pasta with vodka sauce | $ 10.95 |
| Pasta w.Alfredo Sauce Choice of pasta with spinach & alfredo sauce | $ 10.95 |
| Pasta w.Clam Sauce (Red) Choice of pasta with calm sauce | $ 13.95 |
| Pasta w.Clam Sauce (White) Choice of pasta with clam sauce | $ 13.95 |
| Stuffed Shells (4pcs) Stuffed shells with ricotta cheese cooked in marinara sauce & topped with mozzarella cheese | $ 9.50 |
| Ravioli Raviolis stuffed with ricotta cheese baked in marinara sauce | $ 9.50 |
| Lasagna Baked layers of lasagna, ground beef with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese | $ 9.50 |
| Baked Ziti Ziti baked with marinara sauce & topped with mozzarella cheese | $ 9.50 |
| Manicotti Rolls filled with ricotta cheese baked in marinara sauce & topped with mozzarella cheese | $ 9.50 |
Beverages / Sodas
| Red Bull | $ 2.95 |
| Can | $ 1.25 |
| Bottle 20oz | $ 2.25 |
| Bottle 2 Ltr | $ 3.25 |
| Powerade | $ 2.25 |
| Vitamin Water | $ 2.25 |
| Snapple | $ 2.25 |
| Jiuces | $ 2.25 |
| Water Bottle 16.9oz) | $ 1.00 |
Dessert & Extras
| Carrot Cake | $ 4.00 |
| Tiramisu Cake | $ 3.50 |
| Toasted Almond Cake | $ 3.50 |
| Oreo Cake | $ 3.50 |
| Chocolate Cake | $ 3.50 |
| Cheese Cake | $ 3.50 |
| Red Velvet Cake | $ 2.50 |
| Bownie | $ 2.25 |
| Zeppoles (6) | $ 3.00 |
| Vanilla Cannoli (Small) | $ 1.25 |
| Chocolate Cannoli (Small) | $ 1.25 |
⭐ My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY – Reviews ,Ratings and Customer Feedback
Based on local dining feedback and online reviews:
⭐ Overall Rating: 4.1 / 5
✔ Fresh pizza
✔ Generous portions
✔ Fair pricing
✔ Friendly local service
Customers often praise:
- Consistent taste
- Quick takeout service
- Value for money
This isn’t a luxury restaurant — it’s a solid everyday pizza place, which works in its favor.
- The best pizza on Staten Island! The Margherita Pizza is a must-try. – 5 stars
- Amazing service and delicious food. The lasagna is my personal favorite. – 4.8 stars
- A great spot for family dinners. The staff is super friendly, and the food never disappoints. – 4.6 stars
The restaurant’s attention to detail and commitment to quality make it a standout choice for locals and visitors alike.
🪑 Atmosphere & Dining Experience
- Casual & relaxed seating
- Family-friendly environment
- Quick service for takeout orders
- No pressure, no dress code
Perfect for:
✔ Lunch breaks
✔ Family dinners
✔ Quick pizza cravings
✔ Takeout nights
🤔 Is My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY Worth Visiting?
Yes — especially if you value taste, portion size, and price over hype.
- It’s ideal for locals who want:
- Reliable pizza
- Italian comfort food
- A familiar neighborhood vibe
Not a fine-dining destination — but a true Staten Island local favorite.
📍 Location, Contact & Online Presence
Plan your visit to My Pizza and Restaurant with the details below:
- 📍 Address:- 755 Targee Street Staten Island, NY 10304 SI Expy I-278 West Exit 13B, East Exit 13
- 📞 Phone Number: (718) 720-7777
- 🌐 Google Maps Location: Click Here
- 🌐 Official Website: Click Here
- 📱 Social Media : Instagram & Facebook
🏁 Final Local Verdict
My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY delivers exactly what a neighborhood pizza place should — good food, fair prices, and consistency. If you’re nearby and hungry, it’s a safe and satisfying choice 🍕
❓ FAQs – My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY
- What type of food does My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY serve?
They serve New York–style pizza along with classic Italian-American dishes like pasta, baked entrées, and sides. - Is My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY good for families?
Yes, it’s a family-friendly spot with casual seating and menu options that kids and adults both enjoy. - Does My Pizza and Restaurant offer takeout and delivery?
Yes, the restaurant is popular for takeout, and delivery options are usually available through local services. - What is the most popular item on the menu?
Cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza are the most frequently ordered items by regular customers. - Are the prices affordable at My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY?
Yes, prices are considered reasonable and budget-friendly compared to many Staten Island pizza restaurants. - Is this a dine-in restaurant or mainly for takeout?
Both options are available, but many locals prefer takeout due to fast service and convenience. - Does My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY offer vegetarian options?
Yes, vegetarian pizza toppings and pasta dishes are available. - Is My Pizza and Restaurant a good place for quick meals?
Absolutely. It’s a go-to spot for quick lunches, casual dinners, and late-night pizza cravings. - How is the overall customer rating of My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY?
The restaurant generally receives positive reviews for taste, portion size, and consistent quality. - Is My Pizza and Restaurant Staten Island NY worth visiting?
Yes, if you’re looking for reliable New York–style pizza with a local neighborhood feel, it’s worth a visit.
You can also read